Pull this Cookies & Cream Fudge Ice Cream Shop Pie out of the freezer, add a fudge drizzle and tell 'em how you made it in 15 minutes flat. Why this Ice Cream Pie is so good. Stir in butter. Oreo cookie pie crust; Cool Whip; Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream* chocolate sauce; whisk *The combination of mint chocolate chip ice cream and Oreos is awesome but you can substitute the ice cream … Ingredients. Fold in whipped topping. Easy to make, only 3 ingredients. Refrigerate for 1 hour or until set. Ingredients: 1 Large Box of Ice Cream Sandwiches (quantity 20-24) 1 Tub of Cool Whip (Large or Small, depending on how much you want) 1 Jar of Caramel Sauce (12 oz) Pecans or other nuts if desired (or chocolate chips) Layer bottom of a casserole dish with Ice Cream … Pour into pie … It was devoured at the BBQ and lots of compliments. Cool Whip – you can use lite Cool Whip… Mint Chip Ice Cream – or your favorite ice cream. In a bowl, combine ice cream and peanut butter. Stir in remaining COOL WHIP; spoon over COOL WHIP … Press onto the bottom and up the sides of greased 9-in. Ice Cream Sandwich Pie Recipe. I needed 2 pies so I doubled the recipe- 1/2 gal ice cream 12 oz lemonade concentrate and 16 oz of cool whip and I ended up w/ 2 pies and more left over … ... Cover with half the COOL WHIP. 2. pie plate. Make your own Dairy Queen style ice cream pie at home. Beat pudding mixes and milk in large bowl with whisk 2 min. Can be made in any flavor! A delicious Oreo or graham cracker crust. Set aside 1 tablespoon of wafer crumbs for garnish. Freeze 10 min. (Mixture will be thick.) In a bowl, combine the sugar and remaining crumbs.