The WinkBed is shipped rolled up in a box, and the package is heavy. Their flagship Saatva mattress is made with an innerspring base layer, then a layer of … Plus, many brands offer essentially the same mattress under different names at different stores. Return or exchange within: 365 days (fees apply) Asteria Beth (Pillow Top) from Bloomingdale’s. It’s shown here on a mahogany platform bed sold by the company. Thickness: 12⅝ inches Although it’s not that line’s least expensive offering, it’s still half the price of the average mattress in the line yet it offers the added touch of memory foam (created by designers of the Tempur-Adapt, one of our recommended foam mattresses). Restonic’s ComfortCare Pillow Top mattresses come in a variety of firmness levels and heights, which will mostly be influenced by the thickness of the Pillow top layer. Those who liked it extolled its “cradling” and “cloudlike” feel and solid edge support, qualities that are rare among less expensive mattresses. My husband, a back-sleeper weighing just under 200 pounds, liked it as well. What it feels like: The Pillow Top Firm feels firm, but the cushioning on top makes it veer toward medium-firm territory. Casper has eight mattresses in its newly updated line. The Saatva Classic doesn’t have as many support coils as the WinkBed or the Charles P. Rogers Estate SE, nor our cheaper picks, for that matter. The Biltmore mattress collection is the most recent addition to Restonic’s mattress lines and was designed to reflect the luxury details of the Biltmore house, a mansion located in Asheville, North Carolina. The metal coils that traditionally act as the bones of an innerspring mattress now come in a lot more shapes, sizes (including tiny micro-coils), and constructions, and they can be individually wrapped (pocketed) or not, to make the entire bed feel more or less jiggly. We recommend considering the ComfortCare Firm or the Biltmore Hybrid for this sleeping position. This mattress gave us a heavy-duty feel similar to that of the Charles P. Rogers Estate SE but with a firmer, more traditional cushioning sensation. Materials: Talalay latex, Dupont Sorona fiber, pocketed coils; cotton cover The Biltmore Hybrid is available in 11”, 12”, and 13” models and varying firmness levels. The bed has some bounce, but not so much that my husband’s rolling over woke me up. The Biltmore Hybrid is an 11” tall mattress that features a stretch knit, quilted cover, two layers of comfort foam (1” memory foam and 1” medium support foam), and a support core of 14.5” individually wrapped coils. Return or exchange within: 365 days for an exchange only (fees apply) This flippable two-piece mattress is made with high-quality, durable materials—such as latex and extra-sturdy coils—that are rare even in more expensive mattresses. We’ve also included promising mattresses that we didn’t end up naming as picks in our Notable contenders section. Sealy Response Performance in Cushion Firm ($500): This is a budget-friendly mattress that doesn’t feel flimsy and appeals to back- and stomach-sleepers. Key specs The pillow top feels cushy but not outright plush, as the name promises. We like these six medium-firm mattresses best for stomach-sleepers because they’ll support and cushion your midsection while still aligning your spine. If you regularly sleep on your side, you’ll likely want a cushy mattress that aligns your spine and offers good support. Return or exchange within: 100 days Offering a classic innerspring bounce paired with a cushy but understated Euro top, the Saatva appeals to those who want to nestle in as opposed to feeling engulfed. We think the Helix Plus is worth considering. Given its higher price even on sale (we’ve seen it as low as around $3,000), we believe people would get more value from either the Asteria Beth on sale or the Charles P. Rogers Estate SE, each of which is also made of Talalay latex. Thickness: 11½ or 14½ inches Photo: Sarah Kobos, The WinkBed’s pillowy top transitions into a stable-feeling edge. Latex is known for having a more responsive feel than memory foam and for reducing heat retention. Firmness options: Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer, Plus (for those over 300 pounds) A thick quilted organic-cotton cover adds nuance to the surface’s plush feel. Restonic earns points for its wide variety of mattress styles, firmness levels, add-ons, and heights. They come with a wrapped-coil innerspring, a few layers of foam and gel, and a quilted knit cover. Firmness—like comfort—is subjective. Euro tops are actually much thicker than pillow top because they use more material. Back-sleepers and stomach-sleepers may find it too soft. A tester who liked it said it felt “squishy and soft, yet supportive.”. There is no actual “best” mattress for back-pain sufferers, though one that feels medium-firm to you is likely to be the best choice. More than 1,000 pocketed coils at the bottom provide pleasing support for all sleep positions. Avocado Green Mattress ($1,400): This trendy mattress is made of all natural and organic materials, including cotton, wool, and Dunlop latex, and the layers are pulled together with tufting to avoid the use of glues. A return can be a pain—you have to bring your mattress to a store. The key is to know what you’re getting. I’ve also assessed good-quality online customer reviews to gauge trends regarding common complaints and other feedback about mattresses. Firmness options: Plush, Medium Firm, Firm I’ve visited mattress factories and showrooms, shopped undercover at mattress and furniture stores, and conducted more than a hundred hours of interviews with sleep doctors, materials science experts, mattress manufacturers, and mattress sellers. Key specs *At the time of publishing, the price was $1,200. I slept uninterrupted on my back and stomach when I tried out this mattress at home. Here’s everything you should know about the brand’s hybrid and memory-foam beds (and the one we think is worth the money). Altogether, as one tester observed, “this mattress did not feel cheap.”, The Estate SE’s topper consists of a substantial-feeling cotton-blend cover that’s quilted and zipped over layers of Talalay latex and breathable fibers. The 13-inch-thick Charles P. Rogers Estate SE combines high-quality materials, such as extra-strong coils and durable, breathable latex, in an unusual two-piece design. Memory foam and polyfoam make for a cushy top that will especially appeal to side-sleepers. This lofty, upscale-looking bed updates the strong support you might expect from a classic innerspring with a memory-foam cushioning. The difference is that the Avocado model has latex while the Parachute mattress uses organic cotton and wool, which gives it a plusher feel than the Avocado has. The quilted latex-and-fiber topper (a separate piece) provides a cushiony surface without being too billowy. The Biltmore Shippable Sleep mattress is one of two mattresses available for direct purchase on Here are our favorites, plus what you need to know to find one that’s right for you. The warranties protect you against defects in workmanship. I felt buoyed up by the coils, yet the surface offered just the right amount of cuddle.